Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Archive of NZ Weather & Climate
Forum rules
These topics are a read-only archive and may be subject to out-of-date information.

For today's weather discussion head to: New Zealand Weather & Climate
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

one interesting thing about the rain radar is the 'kink' in the line about where it occured...
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
User avatar
Nev
Moderator
Posts: 6216
Joined: Tue 07/03/2006 15:24
Location: Waiheke Island, Hauraki Gulf
Has thanked: 468 times
Been thanked: 1064 times

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Nev »

MS now suggesting that it was a 'downburst'…

'Devastating Auckland wind gusts caused by collapse of air' - NZ Herald
Orion
Posts: 3994
Joined: Sun 08/08/2010 16:49
Location: Ashburton, Mid-Canterbury, 110m asl.
Has thanked: 1367 times
Been thanked: 329 times

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Orion »

For what it's worth, my Silverdale Spy texted last night "Great rainfall at 5:30! and all over in ten minutes. Spoutings overflowed, thunder rolled and as Ak. does, sun came out".
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

I thought M/S might say that going on the fact that the rain suddenly fell out of the cloud...but that occured on the city side of the harbour...not where the tornado occured
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

downbursts dont produce a narrow path of destruction only a few metres wide like what occured
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
User avatar
Tornado Tim
Moderator
Posts: 4920
Joined: Sun 19/10/2008 17:17
Location: Raglan, Waikato / Hillcrest, Hamilton
Has thanked: 102 times
Been thanked: 202 times
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Tornado Tim »

Nev wrote:MS now suggesting that it was a 'downburst'…

'Devastating Auckland wind gusts caused by collapse of air' - NZ Herald
Metservice's Dan Corbett wrote:The downbursts are "very localised"
Hang on here, I think he has got things confused here.

How on earth can he claim that downdrafts of thunderstorms are very localised, that completely fly's in the face what Meteorologists are tought. Despite the line of storms being rather thin, the supposed downdraft would have affected much more people than it did.

It astounds me why Metservice cant take witness testimony seriously In previous articles the press interviewed a woman who actually saw things being lifted up in a shaft of rain, and yet they completely dismissed this.

They come across as very sceptical about what people see, even when I reported stuff a while back via the phone on some storms I felt that I was treated like I didn't know what I was talking about and the equipment I was using to record the event was sub-par and things needed to be verified. They seem to treat that there equipment is always correct and everyone else's equipment is wrong. What process honestly do I and my WX station need to go through in order to be taken seriously by them?

It's soooo extremely frustrating how they dont take what people say seriously.
NZAPStrike.net - NZ Aus Pacific Strike Network
User avatar
NZstorm
Posts: 11333
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 19:38
Location: Grey Lynn, Auckland
Has thanked: 342 times
Been thanked: 361 times

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by NZstorm »

Tornadoes were being forecast by Met Service in the two days prior to the event so they must have thought the potential was there.
User avatar
03Stormchaser
Moderator
Posts: 4428
Joined: Tue 09/12/2003 12:11
Location: Prebbleton
Has thanked: 104 times
Been thanked: 184 times
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by 03Stormchaser »

Metservice obviously dont read what goes on in here! Been losing respect for them since Dan has come on-board tbh.

I don't get it, they forecasted tornadoes, one happens so you think they would be jumping up and down with glee but they don't want to confirm one actually happened...

Mind you WW called it a straight line winds, right after quoting this from a witness "

"Victoria Silvey, 12, was in her lounge when she saw timber, leaves and poles "floating in the air''.
They were whirling around in a funnel that lasted about 30 seconds before leaving the area, she said."

http://www.weatherwatch.co.nz/content/s ... m=facebook
NZ Largest Storm Chasing Facebook Pagehttp://www.facebook.com/nzstormchasers
NZ Largest Storm Chase Community https://www.facebook.com/groups/NZStormchasersGroup
NZ Stormchasers TV https://www.youtube.com/@NZStormchasers
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

yeah, it does not make sense
tornadoes were in the forecast and in the watches
and then when one occurs......it could not possibly be one...?

and it does not make sense to explain that a very narrow path of destruction (i.e by a small tornado...due to at surface wind shear (there are videos captured of narrow small tornadoes...that are only a few metres wide..but which can wreck half a tree or half a fence etc) was instead caused by a downdraft (which would result in a wider destruction path)

re Steve:
yes been lots of eye witness reports of swirling winds , objects floating up in the air (how else do you get roofing iron drapped over power lines ?)
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

I guess M/S are saying upper level dynamics did not look so good after the 1pm sounding...
but they should not go on that alone...topography can easily set off a surfaced based spinner (small twister)
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
User avatar
NZstorm
Posts: 11333
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 19:38
Location: Grey Lynn, Auckland
Has thanked: 342 times
Been thanked: 361 times

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by NZstorm »

Manukau heads obs wrote:I guess M/S are saying upper level dynamics did not look so good after the 1pm sounding...
but they should not go on that alone...topography can easily set off a surfaced based spinner (small twister)
Upper level dynamics were excellent apart the from the fact that there could have been more speed shear aloft. But the instability on the day was not that great and we did need that surface heating to get our storm. Spwills photos show an outflow nature to the convection so certainly some outflow gusts occurring. Grey Lynn got a 42kt gusts which is a rare strength for that site as it is a bit sheltered.
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

there was surface heating though, especially when the original front disentegrated and the started to come out
and especially in the area NW of Auckland
10cm soil temperatures have been as high as 16C lately too
Last edited by Manukau heads obs on Thu 10/10/2013 09:01, edited 1 time in total.
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
spwill
Posts: 9907
Joined: Sun 29/06/2003 22:39
Location: Mt Eden Auckland
Has thanked: 839 times
Been thanked: 866 times

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by spwill »

Clouds go up and down along those lines, the ground reports at Devonport mean you have to consider tornado as a strong possibility but a very short lived and weak event.
Last edited by spwill on Thu 10/10/2013 09:04, edited 1 time in total.
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

yeah,,,it now seems like the stance from M/S is lets call it a down burst unless there is video evidence of a tornado

because down burst winds can do some strange things

but the key is that either side of the narrow path of destruction there was no wind damage

you are not going to get a down burst wind that flows along only a few metre wide path now are you
please explain that to me
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
ben g
Posts: 166
Joined: Tue 20/03/2012 20:32
Location: Belmont,north shore, Auckland
Has thanked: 11 times
Been thanked: 4 times

Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by ben g »

Orion
Posts: 3994
Joined: Sun 08/08/2010 16:49
Location: Ashburton, Mid-Canterbury, 110m asl.
Has thanked: 1367 times
Been thanked: 329 times

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Orion »

A great and comprehensive portfolio of photos, ben g - thankyou very much.
The two I find most interesting are: the roofing that appears to be positively wrapped around the power-lines; and the garage door that seems to have been pushed out of the garage :-k
I'll leave it to others to draw inferences: again, well done. =D>
jamie
Posts: 5907
Joined: Fri 25/02/2011 21:35
Location: Hamilton NZ
Has thanked: 22 times
Been thanked: 273 times
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by jamie »

Nice Ben - I find a couple of things compelling that point towards a tornado.

1) the way that roof is hanging over just some of the lines and not all of them. Says to me its dropped vertically rather than hit it horizontally.

2) the pole (trampoline pole is it?) that has gone through the fence. That takes some wikid force. To me the forces of a tornado that can carry it and throw it. I just cant see straight line winds causing that object to become such a missile.

3) the photo where the fence has fallen to the right towards the garden and path. There is a branch in the foreground that has fallen to the left and is resting on a gate.

4) the garage door has been sucked out. The only possible way that straight line winds could have done that is if the garage is not well built and air is able to freely enter the building from the opposite side to the garage door, or if the wind just happened to be blowing at the perfect angle that the garage faces (ie heading away from where the main door is).This may have caused a deep enough suction and low pressure on the door to pop it outwards.
I tend to believe the low pressure of a tornado is the more obvious answer though.

Combine all this and the very clear multiple eye witness accounts of floating and swirling debris clouds and an actual funnel, i have no idea how metservice and weather watch can claim it's not a tornado.
User avatar
NZstorm
Posts: 11333
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 19:38
Location: Grey Lynn, Auckland
Has thanked: 342 times
Been thanked: 361 times

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by NZstorm »

The roof damage on the bungalow makes this an F1 tornado event.

edited for typo
Last edited by NZstorm on Fri 11/10/2013 21:56, edited 1 time in total.
spwill
Posts: 9907
Joined: Sun 29/06/2003 22:39
Location: Mt Eden Auckland
Has thanked: 839 times
Been thanked: 866 times

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by spwill »

Some other points, a report saying the main rain event had already passed through the area however it was still raining at the time, the duration of the wind was very short, a report of 4 seconds.
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

well that then is very telling
that means it was at the "rain free base" end of the CB
and this whole CB collapse event did not occur until the city CBD side of the harbour
(which is what Ricky actually got with the 80kmh wind gusts)
so it was not a micro burst event
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
Philip Duncan
Posts: 519
Joined: Mon 27/08/2007 21:02
Location: Waitakere City
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Philip Duncan »

You make some fair arguments guys - let me forward some of this to a tornado expert at the Weather Channel in the US. See if he can shed some light. If he agrees there's a higher likelihood it was a tornado I'll happily put a story out to the media and acknowledge the forum's efforts in gathering the evidence and making the case. With regards to Dan Corbett, I would've thought his experience in the US - specifically around tornadoes - might have given him the upper hand on this one.

Cheers
Phil.
User avatar
03Stormchaser
Moderator
Posts: 4428
Joined: Tue 09/12/2003 12:11
Location: Prebbleton
Has thanked: 104 times
Been thanked: 184 times
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by 03Stormchaser »

Philip Duncan wrote:You make some fair arguments guys - let me forward some of this to a tornado expert at the Weather Channel in the US. See if he can shed some light. If he agrees there's a higher likelihood it was a tornado I'll happily put a story out to the media and acknowledge the forum's efforts in gathering the evidence and making the case.
Much appreciated Phil!
NZ Largest Storm Chasing Facebook Pagehttp://www.facebook.com/nzstormchasers
NZ Largest Storm Chase Community https://www.facebook.com/groups/NZStormchasersGroup
NZ Stormchasers TV https://www.youtube.com/@NZStormchasers
User avatar
Tornado Tim
Moderator
Posts: 4920
Joined: Sun 19/10/2008 17:17
Location: Raglan, Waikato / Hillcrest, Hamilton
Has thanked: 102 times
Been thanked: 202 times
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Tornado Tim »

Philip Duncan wrote:You make some fair arguments guys - let me forward some of this to a tornado expert at the Weather Channel in the US. See if he can shed some light. If he agrees there's a higher likelihood it was a tornado I'll happily put a story out to the media and acknowledge the forum's efforts in gathering the evidence and making the case. With regards to Dan Corbett, I would've thought his experience in the US - specifically around tornadoes - might have given him the upper hand on this one.

Cheers
Phil.
Thank you Phil :)
NZAPStrike.net - NZ Aus Pacific Strike Network
jamie
Posts: 5907
Joined: Fri 25/02/2011 21:35
Location: Hamilton NZ
Has thanked: 22 times
Been thanked: 273 times
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by jamie »

Thanks Phil - Thats a great idea
Manukau heads obs
Posts: 12305
Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 16:30
Location: West Coast Road, Manukau Peninsula, North Island
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0
Contact:

Re: Thunderstorms possible North Island 8 October

Unread post by Manukau heads obs »

good idea
because once you have downburst tinted glasses on, its hard to be be pursuaded otherwise...
Image
Brian Hamilton, weather enthusiast. My weather dataEmail: [email protected]
Locked