Weather gurus differ on deluge intensity
Forum rules
These topics are a read-only archive and may be subject to out-of-date information.
For today's weather discussion head to: New Zealand Weather & Climate
These topics are a read-only archive and may be subject to out-of-date information.
For today's weather discussion head to: New Zealand Weather & Climate
-
- Posts: 295
- Joined: Wed 12/03/2003 19:15
- Location: Hillmorton, Christchurch
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Weather gurus differ on deluge intensity
Interesting story in the Southland Times today where Bob McDavitt and Augie Auer disagree on the intensity of the deluge in Belfour on Tuesday (4th).
http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/southlandt ... 11,00.html
"The short, sharp downpour cut off roads, buildings and communication systems across the province on Tuesday. Peter Davidson said yesterday he recorded 58mm of rain in 15 minutes at his Balfour property from about 6pm on Tuesday night. He had no doubt about the amount of rain, which added up to about 50mm in 15 minutes on another neighbour's gauge, Mr McKenzie said."
Mr McDavitt said he doubted the accuracy of the Balfour gauges. MetService equipment in nearby Lumsden recorded 24mm in the hour from 5pm to 6pm.
As we well know on this group, high intensity rainfall can vary widely over an area and as no officially calibrated rain gauge was in the deluge, it can't be counted as official.
Interesting the comments on summer...
The experts did not agree on the forecast either. Mr McDavitt thought summer was just around the corner: "just keep waiting".
But Mr Auer, who several months ago correctly predicted flooding in Southland around Christmas time, was pessimistic. "You might get the odd fine day or two but I've already written summer off."
http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/southlandt ... 11,00.html
"The short, sharp downpour cut off roads, buildings and communication systems across the province on Tuesday. Peter Davidson said yesterday he recorded 58mm of rain in 15 minutes at his Balfour property from about 6pm on Tuesday night. He had no doubt about the amount of rain, which added up to about 50mm in 15 minutes on another neighbour's gauge, Mr McKenzie said."
Mr McDavitt said he doubted the accuracy of the Balfour gauges. MetService equipment in nearby Lumsden recorded 24mm in the hour from 5pm to 6pm.
As we well know on this group, high intensity rainfall can vary widely over an area and as no officially calibrated rain gauge was in the deluge, it can't be counted as official.
Interesting the comments on summer...
The experts did not agree on the forecast either. Mr McDavitt thought summer was just around the corner: "just keep waiting".
But Mr Auer, who several months ago correctly predicted flooding in Southland around Christmas time, was pessimistic. "You might get the odd fine day or two but I've already written summer off."
- 03Stormchaser
- Moderator
- Posts: 4431
- Joined: Tue 09/12/2003 12:11
- Location: Prebbleton
- Has thanked: 105 times
- Been thanked: 185 times
- Contact:
it sounds like two people recorded similar amounts in the same area, so could be possible
yeah summer this year is a write off, might aswell cash it in and wait for next summer!
yeah summer this year is a write off, might aswell cash it in and wait for next summer!
NZ Largest Storm Chasing Facebook Pagehttp://www.facebook.com/nzstormchasers
NZ Largest Storm Chase Community https://www.facebook.com/groups/NZStormchasersGroup
NZ Stormchasers TV https://www.youtube.com/@NZStormchasers
NZ Largest Storm Chase Community https://www.facebook.com/groups/NZStormchasersGroup
NZ Stormchasers TV https://www.youtube.com/@NZStormchasers
- NZstorm
- Posts: 11333
- Joined: Mon 10/03/2003 19:38
- Location: Grey Lynn, Auckland
- Has thanked: 342 times
- Been thanked: 361 times
The atmosphere was quite cold on that day too. The 500mb temperature was -21C and the freezing level looked to be around 2000m. PW was 21mm. Surface dewpoints were around 13C. The colder atmosphere makes it much less likely that such an intense shower (58mm in 15minutes) could have occured. If cb's got particularly active (higher CAPE due to strong surface heating) the resultant precipitation would have been hail stones, not water. The farmers would have been looking at white paddocks, not floods.
The ground down there is very sodden at the moment so any deluge would cause surface flooding. That explains all the surface water they reported.
The ground down there is very sodden at the moment so any deluge would cause surface flooding. That explains all the surface water they reported.
- 03Stormchaser
- Moderator
- Posts: 4431
- Joined: Tue 09/12/2003 12:11
- Location: Prebbleton
- Has thanked: 105 times
- Been thanked: 185 times
- Contact:
so how would you explain two people getting similar rainfalls??NZstorm wrote:The atmosphere was quite cold on that day too. The 500mb temperature was -21C and the freezing level looked to be around 2000m. PW was 21mm. Surface dewpoints were around 13C. The colder atmosphere makes it much less likely that such an intense shower (58mm in 15minutes) could have occured. If cb's got particularly active (higher CAPE due to strong surface heating) the resultant precipitation would have been hail stones, not water. The farmers would have been looking at white paddocks, not floods.
The ground down there is very sodden at the moment so any deluge would cause surface flooding. That explains all the surface water they reported.
NZ Largest Storm Chasing Facebook Pagehttp://www.facebook.com/nzstormchasers
NZ Largest Storm Chase Community https://www.facebook.com/groups/NZStormchasersGroup
NZ Stormchasers TV https://www.youtube.com/@NZStormchasers
NZ Largest Storm Chase Community https://www.facebook.com/groups/NZStormchasersGroup
NZ Stormchasers TV https://www.youtube.com/@NZStormchasers
-
- Posts: 2363
- Joined: Sun 18/01/2004 18:59
- Location: Omarama
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
Speaking from personal experience, I can say that the vast majority of people, if not actually everybody, always grossly overestimate the rate and totals when it comes to rain.
Our electronic gauges were often criticised for "under-reading", yet when we compared their data with that from manual gauges, they were actually over-reading slightly, due to splash (we had them sitting on wide, flat surfaces...they are now mounted on rigid poles).
I've yet to meet anybody who is accurate when it comes to rainfall estimation.
It looks heavy, it sounds heavy, it feels heavy...but is it really heavy?
Our electronic gauges were often criticised for "under-reading", yet when we compared their data with that from manual gauges, they were actually over-reading slightly, due to splash (we had them sitting on wide, flat surfaces...they are now mounted on rigid poles).
I've yet to meet anybody who is accurate when it comes to rainfall estimation.
It looks heavy, it sounds heavy, it feels heavy...but is it really heavy?
- Michael
- Posts: 7210
- Joined: Thu 27/03/2003 12:04
- Location: Rainy Manurewa, Auckland - "City of Gales"
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 1 time
- Contact:
_________________03 Stormchaser wrote:it sounds like two people recorded similar amounts in the same area, so could be possible
yeah summer this year is a write off, might aswell cash it in and wait for next summer!
"They say Poland is the Mexico of Europe. I don't know what that means, but I like it."
It means N.Z is the Iceland of Antarctica
As for summer we may get a dryer spell in March/April
-
- Posts: 2363
- Joined: Sun 18/01/2004 18:59
- Location: Omarama
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0